With The Beatles album cover

Not a Second Time

1963 · With The Beatles

“You're giving me the same old line”

Lennon's spare Smokey Robinson pastiche, famed for The Times critic William Mann's December 1963 review that compared its V-vi turnaround to Mahler's 'Aeolian cadence' - the article that helped legitimize the Beatles for the broadsheet press.

What is unique about this song?

This song is one of three that were recorded with a Baldwin Satin Ebony Grand, with 'Money (That's What I Want)' and 'You Really Got a Hold on Me' as its company, and one of the fragile Lennon songs, showing his more insecure side. It also shows the mark of classical music.

affiliate link - supports this wiki

What happened around it?

see full timeline →

'I Wanna Be Your Man' and 'Little Child' were on the same day's tape. It was cut in the single session that made most of With The Beatles. In the background, 3 weeks before the session, the She Loves You / I'll Get You single came out. President Kennedy was assassinated, which was the day of With The Beatles' release.

Did you know?more like this →

The Anger motif first appears in the Beatles catalogue on 'Not a Second Time' (1963).

● tap a tag for its page and notes

Text144 tags

This song reaches for motifs of anger, relationship and self reflection. Worth noting, the title carries a number ('second') and also carries a no or a not, and no Beatles record before this one was the same. The writing draws on R&B. Intentional or not, the line "No no no" turns up in 4 Beatles songs, among them 'She Said She Said', 'I'm So Tired' and 'Devil in Her Heart'.

affiliate link - supports this wiki

Music137 tags

'Not a Second Time' moves at about 93 BPM in G major, a pop and ballad song with classical music influences (William Mann's 'Aeolian cadence' notice in The Times). It has a keyboard solo, and curiously, the harmony moves G → Em → G → Em → D, which 'Happiness Is a Warm Gun' does as well.

affiliate link - supports this wiki

Studio11 tags

Cut in nine takes at EMI Studio 2 with no Harrison. George Martin played the piano including the solo. Lennon played the Gibson J-160E on it, his acoustic. The kit in the room included the Ludwig Downbeat, which turns up on 17 of that year's records. The Beatles used double tracked vocal on it, and it is on more of their 1964 records than any other year's. Five songs were started the day this one was, the 27th to the 31st of their career.

affiliate link - supports this wiki

Info14 tags

The record reached the public on November 22, 1963, with With The Beatles, and was never a single. In America it arrived eight weeks later, on Meet The Beatles!, a Capitol record. This is their 31st record, and the 29th of the 32 they released in that year.

affiliate link - supports this wiki

Sources & references

Tags on this page are original analysis, transcribed and cross-checked against the fine work of others: Alan W. Pollack's “Notes on…” series, the Beatles Complete Scores (Hal Leonard), Mark Lewisohn's session histories, Ian MacDonald's Revolution in the Head, Dave Rybaczewski's Beatles Music History and Andy Babiuk's Beatles Gear for the instruments and studio equipment, and others besides - then verified by ear against the recordings. Full bibliography: Sources & thanks.

Updated

Feedback

Got a tag idea for Not a Second Time? Or think we've got it all wrong - no, no, no? Don't let it be.