Beatlesongs.wiki
Songs
Albums
Years
People
Categories
Insights
Help
Support
Beatlesongs.wiki

A splendid tagging database of the complete Beatles catalogue – for the scholars, the dreamers, and the ones who've listened to Abbey Road more times than they can count.

Explore

SongsAlbumsYearsPeopleCategoriesGlossary (A–Z)

Insights

All InsightsTimelineBeatle DNATag NetworkWord CloudTag Cloud

Help

AboutFAQWhat's NewContactSuggest a tagSomething's wrongTerms of UsePrivacy PolicyAccessibility Support this wiki

© 2026 Nadav (Nahdi) Lazar. Beatles music © Apple Corps. Fan-made – not affiliated with The Beatles or Apple Corps.

“In the end, the love you take is equal to the love you make.”

SongsBeatles For SaleNo Reply
I'll Be Back·I'm a Loser
No Reply1964 · Beatles For Sale
Beatles For Sale album cover

No Reply

1964 · Beatles For Sale

“I saw you walk in your door”

Lennon's jealousy-fuelled confrontation song, opening Beatles For Sale and showcasing his confident songwriting maturity. Publisher Dick James told Lennon it was his first complete song, with proper resolution rather than just middle-eight escape.
VinylCD

affiliate link – supports this wiki

advertisement
Did you know?more like this →

This song is the only Beatles song with a I to III section transition.

1964I to III
Year1964
AlbumBeatles For Sale
Track1 · Album opener · Side opener · Side 1
Duration2:15
Songwriter(s)LennonCredited as Lennon–McCartney
Lead VocalJohn
RecordedSeptember 30, 1964
ReleasedDecember 4, 1964
Song familyTwin songsTwin of Things We Said Today: shared chorus feel.

● hover for more info● long-press tags for more info

Text262 tags

Motif

RelationshipCommunicationTelephoneDialoguePleaAutobiographyAnatomyHomeLightTruth

Title

Negation in title

Vocabulary

Negative tone

Narrative

First personConversationalSecond person

Rhyme type

Identical rhymeTriple rhymeInternal rhymePerfect rhyme

Song form

AABA formNo verse-chorus

Sections

Has bridgeStandard verses (2-4)No chorusHas outroHas coda

Section links

Outro based on verseCoda based on verse

Repetition

Recurring lineConsecutive lineRecurring verseConsecutive verses
Word cloud

Recurring words

diedfaceforgiveguyhappenedlielieslightlookedonceotherplacerealisetriedwalkedwindowand i'llanother mancause youi camei lookedi nearlyif iin handknow whereman inme causeme nomy placeonce beforesaid yousaw thesaw yousee yourthat's athe lightthey saidthrough yourto seeto yourtried toup towere youwith anotheryou sawyour dooryour faceyour windowcause i knowi saw thei saw youlove you moreto your doorwith another manyou gave melove you more than

Cover-shared words

anotheranycamecausedoorgavehandheardhomeitknowlovemanmemoremysaidsawseetheywalkyouyourbut icame tocause ihand ini knowi sawin myin yourknow thatlove youmore thanthat ithat youwhen iwhen youyou butyou gaveyou moreyou walkyou wereyou've beeni know thatknow that youyou but iyou more thani know that you

Lyric shape

[ADV] that's[NOUN] no[VERB] before[VERB] where[WORD] beforei'd [WORD]in [VERB]not [ADV]the [VERB]with [WORD][VERB] [VERB] in[VERB] in [VERB][VERB] me no[VERB] the [VERB][VERB] to [NOUN][VERB] to your[VERB] up to[VERB] with [WORD][WORD] than [WORD][WORD] that iand i'll [VERB]i [ADV] [VERB]i [VERB] thei [VERB] upi [VERB] wherein [VERB] withme [NOUN] ime no [NOUN]that's a [NOUN]this [NOUN] [WORD]to your [NOUN]with [WORD] [NOUN]you [VERB] in[NOUN] in my [NOUN][VERB] [VERB] in [VERB][VERB] i [ADV] [VERB][VERB] i [VERB] the[VERB] in [VERB] with[VERB] in your [NOUN][VERB] the [NOUN] that[VERB] to your [NOUN][VERB] up to [VERB][VERB] you [VERB] in[WORD] through your [NOUN]i [VERB] up toi'll [VERB] the [NOUN]when i [VERB] towhen you [VERB] meyou [VERB] me [NOUN][VERB] you [WORD] than [WORD]that you [VERB] me [NOUN]

Cover-shared shape

[NOUN] i[NOUN] in[NOUN] they[NOUN] you[VERB] i[VERB] in[VERB] it[VERB] me[VERB] no[VERB] that[VERB] the[VERB] to[VERB] up[VERB] with[VERB] you[VERB] your[WORD] than[WORD] thata [NOUN]i [VERB]i'll [VERB]me [NOUN]my [NOUN]no [NOUN]the [NOUN]they [VERB]this [NOUN]to [NOUN]to [VERB]you [VERB]you [WORD]your [NOUN][NOUN] i [VERB][NOUN] in my[NOUN] they [VERB][NOUN] you [VERB][VERB] i [VERB][VERB] me [NOUN][VERB] no [NOUN][VERB] that i[VERB] that you[VERB] the [NOUN][VERB] you [VERB][VERB] you [WORD][VERB] you were[VERB] your [NOUN][WORD] [NOUN] inbut i [VERB]i [VERB] thati [VERB] toi [VERB] youi'll [VERB] thein my [NOUN]in your [NOUN]that you [VERB]the [NOUN] thatthey [VERB] itthey [VERB] youwhen i [VERB]when you [VERB]you [VERB] [VERB]you [VERB] me[VERB] you [WORD] than[WORD] [NOUN] in mybut i [VERB] youi [VERB] that youi [VERB] you [VERB]i [VERB] you [WORD]to [VERB] your [NOUN]you but i [VERB]you but i [VERB] you

Rhyme scheme

AAAAABCD

Line length

Unique line length

Distinctive word

peepreplytelephone

Music200 tags

Arrangement

Lead vocalsBacking vocalsElectric guitarAcoustic guitarBass guitarPianoDrumsPercussionHandclaps

Instrument group

GuitarsKeyboardsPercussion

Bass work

Stepwise bass line

Music genre

RockPopFolk rock

Vocal work

Two-part harmonyVocal harmoniesMelisma

Tempo

Upbeat

Key

C major

Time signature

4/4

Song form

AABA formNo verse-chorus

Sections

Has bridgeStandard verses (2-4)No chorusHas outroHas coda

Section links

Outro based on verseCoda based on verse

Repetition

Consecutive verses

Section transition

I to IVUnique section transition

Harmony

Modal mixtureCircle of fifthsPerfect cadenceBorrowed chordSecondary dominantPlagal cadenceJazz cadenceThree-chord trick

Composition

Rich harmonyNon-tonic openingTonic endingBridge in IIIVerse in IVNon-tonic verseNon-tonic bridge

Mode

Ionian

Chord type

majorminordom7min7maj7add96

Scale degree

II6ii7iiIII7iiiIVIVmaj7V7VI7vi

Chord degree

IV–VV–II–IVI–vivi–iiiiii–iiii–VIV–V–IV–I–IVI–IV–VV–I–viii–V–IV–I–vi–iiiIV–Ivi–iii–IV–iiiiii–IV–iii–iiI–IIIVI–iiiii–IV–IIV–iiiiii–ii–Vii–IV–IIII–VII–IV–V–I–viIV–iii–iivi–iii–IVI–III–VIIV–I–IIIvi–iii–IV–IVI–ii–IV–Iiii–IVIV–V–I–viii–IVI–vi–iii

Chord shape

C → F → B♭C → DC → D7C → FC7 → FC → AmAm → EmC → BmAm → GmAm → DAm7 → D7C → D → GC7 → F → B♭C → F → GC → F → G7C → F → DmAm → D → GAm7 → D7 → GC → F → Dm → AmC7 → F7C → FmC7 → FmAm → CC → GC → EC → E → AAm → Gm7 → C7C → Am → EmAm → C → GAm → Gm → CC → G → BC → F → G → C → AmC7 → F → Dm → AmC7 → Fm → A♭C → Bm → AmAm → Em → FC → G → B7C → F → B♭mC → E7 → A7Am → Gm7C → Fm → A♭ → E♭Am → Em → F → CC → Am → Em → FC → D7 → G → EmAm → B♭ → Am → GmC → F → G7 → C → AmC → D → G → C → D → G → EmAm → B♭C → E7C → D7 → GC7 → F → DmC → D → G → EmAm → B♭ → FAm → Em → F → EmC → Fm → A♭

Chord literal

F → GF → G7G → CC → FC → AmF → EmEm → DmDm → GDm7 → G7F → G → CG → C → AmDm → G → CDm7 → G7 → CE → AA → DmF → CG → C → Am → EmA → Dm → F → CC → EG → C → FAm → Em → F → CC → E7C → F → GA7 → DmC → Am → EmG7 → C → AmDm → F → CEm → F → CF → G7 → CC → F → G → C → AmC → E → AE7 → A7C → F → G7F → C → E7Dm → FF → C → EG7 → C → FG7 → CF → Em → DmF → G → C → AmAm → EmG7 → C → Am → Em

Studio11 tags

Studio technique

Double tracked vocal

Equipment

Gibson J-160EHofner 500/1Telefunken M10 4-track recorderEMI REDD.51 consoleLudwig Super ClassicSteinway VertegrandGretsch 6119 Tennessean

Recording location

EMI Studio 2EMI Studios

Session duration

Single day
You might also like:deadmau5 – Teaches Electronic Music ProductionTimbaland – Teaches Producing and Beatmaking

affiliate link – supports this wiki

People11 tags

Unique personnel
Producer plays
Line-up
John Lennon
Lead vocalsAcoustic guitarHandclaps
Paul McCartney
Backing vocalsBass guitarHandclaps
George Harrison
Backing vocalsElectric guitarAcoustic guitarHandclaps
Ringo Starr
DrumsHandclaps
George Martin
ProducerPiano
Songwriter
John Lennon
Producer
George Martin
Recording engineer
Norman Smith
Assistant engineer
Ken ScottA. B. LincolnMike Stone

Info17 tags

Release type

Song on albumSong on Anthology

US release

Beatles '65

Release mix

StereoMono

Label

ParlophoneCapitol

Publisher

Northern Songs

Song family

Twin songs

Song type

Original

Duration

Short
You might also like:Waves Abbey Road REDD ConsoleUsher – Teaches the Art of Performance

affiliate link – supports this wiki

Sources & references

Tags on this page are original analysis, transcribed and cross-checked against the fine work of others: Alan W. Pollack's “Notes on…” series, the Beatles Complete Scores (Hal Leonard), Mark Lewisohn's session histories, Ian MacDonald's Revolution in the Head, Dave Rybaczewski's Beatles Music History and Andy Babiuk's Beatles Gear for the instruments and studio equipment, and others besides – then verified by ear against the recordings. Full bibliography: Sources & thanks.

Updated 2026-06-03

advertisement

Feedback

Got a tag idea for No Reply? Or think we've got it all wrong – no, no, no? Don't let it be.

Beatles For Sale album cover
VinylCD

affiliate link – supports this wiki

Year1964
AlbumBeatles For Sale
Track1 · Album opener · Side opener · Side 1
Duration2:15
Songwriter(s)Lennon
Credited asLennon–McCartney
Lead VocalJohn
RecordedSeptember 30, 1964
ReleasedDecember 4, 1964
Song family
Twin songs

Twin of Things We Said Today: shared chorus feel.

You might also like:All the SongsRevolution in the Head

affiliate link – supports this wiki

You might also like:John Legend – Teaches SongwritingThe Musician's Guide to Theory

affiliate link – supports this wiki

You might also like:Beatles For SaleCarlos Santana – Teaches the Art and Soul of Guitar

affiliate link – supports this wiki